Introduction: The Blade and the Belief
In many parts of the world, the word circumcision slices deeper than skin—it cuts into history, culture, religion, identity, masculinity, and medicine. In communities from Nigeria to New York, from Lagos to Los Angeles, it is a decision wrapped in centuries of tradition and modern science. But beneath the surface lies a brewing debate: Is circumcision a health necessity or merely a cultural inheritance? Should it be a parental rite or an adult choice? At the heart of the argument lies a profound human question—where do the boundaries of body autonomy, cultural heritage, and health responsibility begin and end?
For many men, circumcision is not just a surgical procedure—it is a lifelong badge. For some, it was done at birth without consent. For others, it was performed during adolescence in elaborate rites of passage. And for others still, the decision was avoided entirely, leading to feelings of being “different,” or worse, being judged.
This article explores the emotional, medical, and societal tensions surrounding circumcision—especially in cultures where silence and shame drown out informed discussion.
Circumcision Through the Lens of Culture: A Sacred Rite or Social Pressure?
In Nigeria and much of sub-Saharan Africa, circumcision is not merely a hygienic practice—it is a ceremony, a sacred rite of passage that binds boys to manhood and boys to their ancestors. In the southeastern regions, it often takes place in infancy, while in the northern Muslim communities, it might coincide with religious traditions. In rural villages and among indigenous groups, circumcision can involve song, dance, rituals, and storytelling. But what happens when a ritual becomes a rule?
Many men, especially in urban centres like Abuja and Lagos, report never having been given a choice. Some carry scars—both emotional and physical—of painful or unhygienic procedures performed in remote towns or by traditional practitioners. Others recall being mocked or pressured by peers during puberty if they were not circumcised.
In many Nigerian households, the decision is made by parents—usually fathers or uncles—often based on a mixture of pride, belief, and fear of societal judgment. A circumcised son is seen as normal. An uncircumcised one? A subject of whispers, nicknames, or outright rejection.
Yet, as more Nigerians travel, study abroad, and gain access to global information, a quiet revolution is taking place. Young men are beginning to question: “Was this necessary? Was this my choice?”
The Medical View: Health Benefits or Unwarranted Cut?
Science offers a complex answer. Medical bodies like the World Health Organization (WHO) and Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) note certain health benefits of circumcision—reduced risks of urinary tract infections in infancy, lower rates of some sexually transmitted infections (including HIV), and reduced risk of penile cancer.
But the story doesn’t end there.
Critics argue that these benefits are often marginal, especially in developed countries where hygiene and access to healthcare are high. Some studies show that consistent condom use and good sexual hygiene offer the same protections—without the need for surgery.
Others emphasize the risks of complications: excessive bleeding, infection, loss of sensitivity, or even psychological trauma. When performed in infancy, babies cannot consent. When performed in traditional settings, sterilization standards may be poor, increasing the risk of sepsis or disfigurement.
More alarmingly, some health professionals in Nigeria now speak privately about an emerging wave of "corrective circumcisions"—where botched childhood circumcisions must be surgically fixed later in life. These cases are often accompanied by deep emotional pain and body shame.
The Emotional Toll: Silence, Shame, and Scars
The emotional impact of circumcision is often downplayed, especially in male spaces where vulnerability is discouraged. But in reality, many men live with silent trauma.
Some experience long-term sensitivity issues or sexual dysfunction. Others feel a deep sense of violation—especially when the procedure was done without consent. In certain cases, the trauma is linked with identity: men who grow up in cultures where being uncircumcised is taboo often carry a heavy burden of shame, secrecy, and isolation.
A young man from Port Harcourt shared his story online, saying, “I was circumcised at age 5. I still remember the pain. I didn’t understand what was happening. I didn’t even know I was bleeding. My mother told me I’d thank her later. But now, at 32, I’ve struggled with sexual sensitivity for years. And no, I don’t thank her.”
Others speak of embarrassment during relationships, feeling "less than" or fearful of how a partner might react upon discovering they're uncircumcised or have a visibly scarred penis.
These stories are rarely told. They live in the quiet spaces of men's WhatsApp groups, anonymous forums, or therapy sessions—if therapy is even sought at all.
A Cultural Clash: West vs Africa?
In Western countries, circumcision is often approached through the lens of personal choice and medical ethics. There's a growing movement in places like the United States, Canada, and the UK to delay circumcision until a boy can make the decision himself. Some activists label infant circumcision as "genital mutilation"—a term that shocks many Africans but reflects deep ethical concerns.
In contrast, African societies often defend circumcision as cultural preservation, tying it to masculinity, religious obedience, or community cohesion. But does cultural tradition justify bodily alteration without consent?
This debate becomes more charged in diaspora communities. African parents living in Europe or America face social and legal scrutiny over circumcision decisions. Nigerian youths growing up in the UK may ask: “Why was this done to me?” Others may feel conflicted—torn between inherited culture and modern autonomy.
Religion’s Role: Commandment or Custom?
In Islam and Judaism, circumcision holds profound religious weight. For Muslim communities in Nigeria, it is regarded as a Sunnah—a deeply recommended, though not mandatory, act. For Jews, it is a covenantal ritual dating back to Abraham.
Christianity, on the other hand, does not mandate circumcision. In fact, the New Testament explicitly argues against it as a requirement for spiritual righteousness. And yet, many Christian parents in Nigeria still circumcise their sons—mostly out of habit, fear of stigma, or pressure from healthcare providers.
This blurring of religious doctrine and cultural practice raises important questions. Are parents making faith-based decisions—or just following inherited norms?
The Rise of Intactivism: A Global Counter-Movement
In recent years, a movement known as “Intactivism” has gained traction across the globe. It advocates for genital autonomy—the belief that individuals should decide for themselves if they want to be circumcised.
Intactivists argue that no medical benefit justifies permanent body alteration without consent. They call for legal reforms, greater transparency, and public education. Their message is clear: “Let the owner of the body decide.”
In Nigeria, this movement is still in its infancy, partly because discussions about male genitalia are wrapped in taboo. But digital spaces are changing that. Blogs, podcasts, and social media platforms now offer anonymous forums where Nigerian men are beginning to unpack the legacy of their circumcisions.
What Nigerian Doctors Are Saying
While traditional beliefs still dominate, more Nigerian doctors are speaking up about the need for informed consent, standardized practices, and public awareness.
Dr. Adaobi Nwosu, a Lagos-based pediatrician, explains:
"Circumcision isn’t evil. But it must be done with proper hygiene, professional skills, and—most importantly—informed decision-making. Parents must be educated. Boys must be allowed to ask questions when they’re old enough. It should never be automatic."
Dr. Jibrin Lawal, a urologist in Abuja, warns about the “cultural pressure to perform circumcision within days of birth”:
"We see complications from rushed or poorly executed circumcisions all the time. This should not be normal. Nigerian parents need to slow down and ask: Is this really necessary now? Or can my son choose when he's older?"
Toward an Informed Future: Where Do We Go From Here?
-
Education Over Tradition
Cultural practices must evolve with knowledge. Rather than shaming families into conformity, communities should offer honest, non-judgmental education about circumcision's risks, benefits, and alternatives. -
Consent-Centered Healthcare
Hospitals and clinics should adopt policies that prioritize consent, counseling, and parent education. Information leaflets, postnatal workshops, and online platforms can help parents make better decisions. -
Safe, Professional Practices
If parents choose circumcision, it should be done in sterile, clinical settings with trained professionals—not in backyards or traditional huts with razor blades and chants. -
Male Mental Health Support
We must normalize conversations around male trauma, body shame, and sexual dysfunction related to circumcision. Therapy, peer support groups, and male-focused wellness programs can offer healing. -
Respect for Choice
Ultimately, the goal should not be to abolish circumcision—but to humanize it. That means respecting those who choose it for themselves and protecting those who don’t.
Final Thoughts: Cutting Through the Noise
Circumcision will always stir emotion, debate, and discomfort—because it lies at the intersection of our deepest values: identity, masculinity, safety, belief, and love. But what if we could move from silence to conversation? From inherited rituals to informed choices? From cultural pride to compassionate care?
In Nigeria and around the world, the future of circumcision doesn't lie in blades—it lies in voices. Honest, informed, respectful voices that allow every man—every boy—to own his body, his story, and his choice.
Let’s talk.
If you got value from this article and would like to support this blog, you can send in your donations via our PayPal Account >> chenkovwellness@gmail.com
Comments
Post a Comment